The story behind Millennium by Backstreet Boys
Hello and welcome to VinylCast.
It was a year defined by pre-millennial tension, where the glossy sheen of MTV hits masked a brutal reality of betrayal and loss. Behind the screaming fans and the coordinated outfits, five young men were fighting a war on two fronts: a legal battle for their financial lives and a series of crushing personal tragedies that threatened to derail them completely. This is the story of Millennium, the blockbuster third studio album by the Backstreet Boys, released by Jive Records on May 18, 1999.
While the public saw the epitome of pop perfection, the band was locked in a bitter dispute with their manager, Lou Pearlman. Between 1997 and 1998, they filed a lawsuit revealing they had received only three hundred thousand dollars while Pearlman pocketed over ten million. The betrayal deepened when Pearlman, who claimed to be the sixth Backstreet Boy, admitted he was managing their rivals, NSYNC, simply stating it was just business. On September 18, 1998, the group finally left his management company, Wright Stuff.
The recording sessions, which began in early October 1998, were equally fraught with sorrow. Kevin Richardson suffered two family deaths, Howie Dorough lost his sister to lupus, and Brian Littrell had to undergo open-heart surgery. Perhaps the most significant blow was the death of their mentor and producer, Denniz Pop, from stomach cancer. Yet, the group channeled this pain into a sophisticated sound. They collaborated closely with Max Martin, who produced seven of the first eight tracks, crafting a sonic signature that would define the era.
Initially, the band considered titling the album Larger Than Life, a tribute to their fans, but they pivoted to a more timeless concept. In a crucial artistic decision, they rejected the upbeat title track as the lead single to avoid appearing arrogant. Instead, on April 12, 1999, they released I Want It That Way. This mid-tempo masterpiece became a genre-transcending classic, earning nominations for Record of the Year and becoming, surprisingly, their only number-one hit in the United Kingdom.
The commercial response was immediate and overwhelming. Millennium sold nearly five hundred thousand copies on its first day in the U.S. and held the record for the most shipments in a single year, with eleven million units moved in 1999 alone. The album eventually earned five Grammy nominations and was certified thirteen times Platinum. The accompanying Into the Millennium Tour was a marathon of endurance, spanning one hundred and twenty-three shows across eighty-four cities. One historic stop at the Georgia Dome became the most attended concert by a pop artist in American history. Even the promotion was relentless; previews of the songs were hidden on early versions of Britney Spears' debut album to ensure dominance.
With over twenty-four million copies sold worldwide, Millennium was more than just a flash in the pan. It remains a testament to pop perfection constructed amidst chaos, a victory of resilience over tragedy.
Thanks for listening to this podcast, provided to your ears by VinylCast.
Production Personnel & Credits
Musicians, producers, engineers and design credited on this album.
Why this album ranks #27 in our Top 100
Millennium sits at #27 in the VinylCast Top 100 best-selling US vinyl albums (1960–2010), and #6 within Pop. The ranking reconciles RIAA certified shipments with Luminate (Nielsen SoundScan) point-of-sale data, with manual reconciliation for catalog re-releases. See the full Top 100 with methodology.
Frequently asked questions
How was Millennium by Backstreet Boys made?
Listen to the full VinylCast episode above for the verified creation story of Millennium by Backstreet Boys, sourced from published recording-session accounts.


